62|Part 2 of — 28 Shin-To Main 7 Region (part B)

This chapter is a detailed part of Chapter 28, Shin-t Main 7 Regions (part B).  Please read Chapter 28 before reading this chapter.  Below are regions 3 and 7.

0-timeline - size 24 Shin-to                           The red circle above indicates the time we discuss in this section    

29 Map with number 7

3.Musashi (Edo)

We also find many famous swordsmiths in Edo.  They were Yasutsugu (康継), Kotetsu (虎徹), Noda Hankei (野田繁慶), Hojoji Masahiro (法成寺正弘), and their followers.

Two photos below are swordsmiths from Musashi (武蔵: Tokyo).  

                       Yasutsugu  From the Sano Museum Catalogue.  (Permission to use granted)

Characteristics of Yasutusgu (康継) ——Shallow curvature; chu-gissaki (medium kissaki); a wide notare hamon, midare, or o-gunome (occasionally double gunome); traces of Soshu-den and Mino-den; a wood-grain pattern mixed with masame on the shinogi-ji.

 

              Kotetsu (虎徹) from Sano Museum Catalogue, (permission to use granted)

Here is the famous Kotetsu.  His formal name was Nagasone Okisato Nyudo Kotetsu (長曽祢興里入道虎徹).   Kotetsu started making swords after turning 50.  Before that, he was an armor maker.  

The characteristics of Kotetsu ———————— A shallow curvature and wide width, a wide tempered line with nie.  A small irregular hamon surrounds the machi area, transitioning into a wide suguha-like notare in the upper area.  Fine nie, komaruboshi with a short turn backThe ji-hada is a fine-grained wood with burl.  Occasionally, o-hada (black core iron shows through) appears in the lower part above the machi area.  The illustration above shows a thick-tempered line with nie, a typical feature of Kotetsu. Once you see it, you will remember it.   The next region is 7 (skip 4, 5, and 6)

 

  1. Satsuma (Kyushu) 

  Miyahara Mondonosho Masakiyo (宮原主水正正清) from Sano Museum Catalogue (permission to use granted).

Miyahara Mondonosho Masakiyo was highly respected by the Shimazu family of Satsuma- han (the Satsuma domain in Kyushu).  Later, he was chosen to travel to Edo to forge swords for Shogun Yoshimune

Mondonosho Masakiyo’s characteristics————- Well-balanced sword shape, shallow curvature, and wide and narrow hamon mixed with squarish hamon and pointed hamon as shown in the photo above.  He engraved the Tokugawa family’s Aoi crest (the hollyhock crest) on the nakago.

61|Part 2 of — 27 Shin-to Main 7 Regions (part A)

Chapter 61 is a detailed part of Chapter 27, Shinto Main 7 Regions (part A).  Please read Chapter 27 before reading this section. 

0-timeline - size 24 Shin-to                        The red circle above indicates the time we discuss in this section

Chapter 27, Shin-to Main 7 Regions (Part A), and Chapter 28, Shin-to Main 7 Regions (Part B), describe an overview of the seven main regions.  This chapter and the next chapter show photos of representative swords from these regions.  They are Yamashiro (山城, in Kyoto), Settsu (摂津, today’s Osaka), Musashi (武蔵, Edo), and Satsuma (薩摩, Kyushu).  However, Echizen (越前), Kaga (加賀), and Hizen (肥前) are omitted.

29 Map with number 7

With ko-to swords, features such as the condition of the hamon, kissaki size, length, and  shape of the nakago, etc., indicate when the sword was made.  During the ko-to period, Bizen swordsmiths produced Bizen-den swords, Yamashiro swordsmiths made Yamashiro-den swords, and Mino swordsmiths made Mino-den swords.  However, during the shin-to period, that is not the case.  The den and the swordsmith’s location often do not match.  For shin-to swords, we study the swordsmiths and swords from the seven main regions along with their characteristics.

Regarding swords made during the ko-to period, if a sword has a wide hamon line with  nie, usually, its ji-hada shows a large wood grain or a large burl grain.  Also, when you see a narrow hamon line, it typically features a fine ji-hada.

However, with shin-to swords, if a sword shows a wide hamon with nie, it often has a small wood grain or small burl grain pattern on ji-hada.  If it has a narrow hamon line, it may have a large wood grain pattern on the ji-hada.  This is a shin-to characteristic.   

Here is an exception: some early Soshu-den swords from the late Kamakura period may show a wide hamon with nie, which has small burls on the ji-hada.  Because of that, whether it is ko-to or shin-to can be confusing.  Even so, other features such as ji-hada or other parts should indicate whether it is shin-to or ko-to.

Yamashiro (山城: Kyoto)

 Horikawa Kunihiro   (堀川国広)   From Sano Museum Catalogue (permission granted)

Horikawa Kunihiro (堀川国広)

Horikawa Kunihiro was regarded as a master swordsmith among shin-to swordsmiths.  He forged swords in many styles with various characteristics.  The hamon types are o-notare, o-gunome, togari-ba (pointed hamon), chu-suguha with hotsure (frayed look), hiro-suguha with a sunagashi effect, inazuma, and kinsujiKunihiro preferred to shape his swords to resemble an o-suriage (shortened Nanboku-cho style long sword).  Kunihiro‘s blades give a powerful impression.  Kunihiro‘s swords often feature beautiful carvings; designs include dragons, Sanskrit letters, and more.  Because he created swords in many different styles, there is no general characteristic that defines his work other than the hamon mainly being nie.  His ji-hada is finely forged.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     

img067.jpg  img068.jpg      Iga-no-Kami Kinnmichi (伊賀守金道)           Dewa Daijyo Kunimichi (出羽大掾国路)        Both Juyo Token (重要刀剣), once my family owned, photos were taken by my father.

Iga-no-Kami Kinmichi ( 伊賀守金道)

The Kinmichi family is called the Mishina group.  Refer to 27 Shinto Main 7 Regions  Part A.   Iga-no-Kami Kinmichi was awarded the Japanese Imperial chrysanthemum crest. 

The characteristics of Kinmichi ——– Wide sword, shallow curvature, an extended kissaki, sakizori (curvature at 1/3 top),  a wide tempered line, kyo-yakidashi (see 27 Shinto Main 7 Regions  A ), hiro-suguha (wide straight hamon), o-notare (large wavy), yahazu-midare, hako-midare (refer to 24 Sengoku Period Tanto).  Mishina-boshi, refer to 27 Shin-to Main 7 Regions A.  Fine wood burl, masame appear in the shinogi-ji area.   

Dewa Daijo Kunimichi (出羽大掾国路)                                                                                 

Dewa Daijo Kunimichi was the top student of Horikawa Kunihiro.  The right photo above.  Like Kunihiro, the sword resembles a shortened Nanboku-cho sword.  Shallow curvature, a wide body, a somewhat elongated kissaki, and fukura-kareru (less arch in fukura).  Wide tempered lines, large gunome, nie with sunagashi, or inazuma shows.  Double gunome (two gunome side by side) appears.  Fine ji-hada.                                                                                                                                                                                                                

  1. Settu (摂津) Osaka (大阪 )

Settu (Osaka) is home to many famous swordsmiths.  They are Kawachi-no-Kami Kunisuke (河内守国助), Tsuda Echizen-no-Kami Sukehiro (津田越前守助広), Inoue Shinkai (井上真改), and Ikkanshi Tadatsuna (一竿子忠綱), among others.                          The main characteristic of the Settsu (Osaka) sword ——– The surface is beautiful and fine, almost like a solid surface with no pattern or design.  The two photos below are of the Settsu sword.

              Ikkanshi Tadatsuna from the Sano Museum Catalogue.  Permission granted to use.

Ikkanshi Tadatsuna (一竿子忠綱)

Ikkanshi Tadatsuna was famous for his carvings.  His father was also a well-known swordsmith, Omi-no-Kami Tadatsuna (近江守忠綱)Consequently, he was known as Awataguchi Omi-no-Kami Fujiwara Tadatsuna (粟田口近江守藤原忠綱), as shown in the nakago photo above.     

The characteristics of Ikkanshi Tadatsuna ——-A longer kissaki and a wide-tempered line with nie.  The Osaka yakidashi (transition between the suguha above machi and midare is smooth.  Refer to 27 Shin-to Sword – Main 7 Regions (Part A) for details on Osaka yakidashi.  O-notare with gunome, komaru-boshi with a turn back, and very fine ji-hada with almost no pattern on the surface.

                        Inoue Shinkai (井上真改) from “Nippon-to Art Swords of Japan” The Walter A. Compton Collection

Inoue Shinkai (井上真改)

Inoue Shinkai was the second generation of Izumi-no-Kami Kunisada (和泉守国貞), who was a student of Kunihiro.                                                                                                  The characteristic of Inoue Shinkai’s swords —————- Osaka yakidashi, the tempered line gradually widens toward the top.  O-notare and deep nie.  Very fine ji-hada with almost no surface design.

58|Part 2 of — 24 Sengoku Period Tanto (戦国時代短刀)

Chapter 58 is a detailed section of Chapter 24, Sengoku Period Tanto.  Please read Chapter 24, Sengoku Period Tanto, before reading this part. 

0-timeline - size 24 Sengoku Period

           The red circle above indicates the time we discuss in this section  

Muramasa (村正)

This chapter discusses the famous Muramasa (村正).  Usually, many well-known swordsmiths come from one of the Goka-den (五家伝: the five main schools: Yamashiro-den, Bizen-den, Soshu-den, Yamato-den, and Mino-den).  However, Muramasa was not from Goka-den but from Ise Province.  The first-generation Muramasa was known as a student of He’ian-jo Nagayoshi (平安城長吉) of Yamashiro-den.  The Muramasa family existed through the mid-Muromachi period.  They spanned three generations from the mid-Muromachi to the Sengoku period

61 Ise map

Below is one of Muramasa’s tantos, made during the Sengoku period.  Since it was made during the Sengoku era, the blade shows the style of Sengoku-period swords.  It reflects Mino-den characteristics, combined with Soshu-den traits. 

     

 Muramasa (村正) from Sano Museum Catalogue (permission granted)

Characteristics  on this Tanto

Muramasa’s tantos are typically about ten inches ± half an inch or so.  Hirazukuri (平作り). Thin blades with a sharp look.  The nioi base with small nie and sunagashi patterns (brushed sand-like patterns, as shown in the illustration below) appears.  The boshi (the top part of the hamon) is jizo (a side view of a human head).  The tempered line varies with both wide and narrow areas.  Some areas are so narrow, almost close to the edge of the blade, while others are broader.  Hako midare (box-like shape) and gunome (lined-up bead pattern) appear.  O-notare (large, gentle waviness) is a signature characteristic of Muramasa.  The pointed-tempered line is a typical characteristic of Mino-den (Sanbon-sugi).  Refer to Chapter 23, Sengoku Period Sword, and Chapter 24, Sengoku Period Tanto.

                                       

 

50|Part 2 of –16 Late Kamakura Period: Tanto (Early Soshu-Den 鎌倉末短刀, 正宗墓)

Chapter 50 is a detailed part of  Chapter 16, Late Kamakura Period Tanto (Early Soshu-Den).  Please read Chapter 16 before this section.

0-timeline - size 24 Late Kamakura

                     The red circle above indicates the time we discuss in this section.

In  Chapter 16, Late Kamakura Period Tanto (Early Soshu-Den), the general features of the late Kamakura period tanto style (early Soshu-den) are described.  The following two photos show the typical characteristics of early Soshu-den tanto.

Masamune

Goro Nyudo Masamune (五郎入道正宗) was born in Kamakura as the son of Tosaburo Yukimitu (藤三郎行光)Today, Masamune is a well-known swordsmith, even among those unfamiliar with Japanese swords.  His father, Tosaburo Yukimitsu, was also among the top swordsmiths in early Soshu-den.  Masamune’s tomb is located at Honkaku-ji (本覚寺) Temple, about a 6-minute walk from Kamakura Station. 

Goro Nyudo Masamune (五郎入道正宗) Sano Museum Catalog (permission granted)

Masamune photo (above) —– Hira-zukuri (flat).  Sakizori is very slightly curved (the tip area curves slightly outward).  Bo-hi and tsure-hi (parallel thin grooves).  Komaru-boshiItame-hada (wood grain pattern).  The Hamon is notare (wavy).  The illustration above shows sunagashi and niju-ba (double hamon).  This type of nakago is called tanago-bara.  The Masamune tanto is often mu-mei (unsigned). This particular tanto is called Komatsu Masamune (小松政宗).  The catalog from the Sano Museum’s description stated that connoisseurs in the past had difficulty determining this as a Masamune swordBecause the wide mihaba with sori and hamon slightly differed from those of another Masamune.  Judging from the clear nie, chikei, and kinsuji, it was determined to be a Masamune tanto.

Enju Photo below

               Higo Province Enju Kunisuke from Sano Museum Catalog (permission granted)

The Enju (延寿) group lived in Higo (肥後) Province on Kyushu.  The characteristics of the Enju group closely resemble those of the Yamashiro-den because Enju Kunimura was related to Rai Kuniyuki, a member of the Yamashiro-den.

Enju (photo above) —-Hamon is hoso-suguha (straight temper line).  The boshi is komaru.  The front engraving is suken (above left photo, left side), and the engraving on the back is gomabashi (left photo, right side).  Tight itame ji-hada.  It can be confusing to kantei (determine who made the sword) a sword like this because, although it is from the late Kamakura period, it does not have the typical early Soshu-den appearance.

Masamune’s Tomb in Honkaku-ji Temple

Masamune’s (正宗) tomb is located inside Honkaku-ji Temple (本覚寺) in Kamakura.  Here is a map of Honkaku-ji Temple and the Masamune Kogei store in Kamakura.  The store is owned by Tsunahiro Yamamura, the 24th generation of MasamuneHonkaku-ji Temple is circled on the map, and the Masamune Kogei store is a red circle with an X.  Both are about a 6 to 7-minute walk from Kamakura Station. 

To reach to Honkaku-Ji Temple from Tokyo                                                                           Take the Yokosuka Line train from Tokyo Station (approx. one hour) → Get off at Kamakura Station (one stop after Kita-Kamakura) → Exit through the East Exit (front exit) → Walk straight and cross the street → Turn right and walk to the post office → Turn left at the post office (Honkaku-ji Temple sign is at the corner of the post office)

From Kamakura Tourist map

52 Honnkakuji 2 54 large Masamune monument only

52 Honkakuji 54 Small Masamune tomb only

Honkakuji Temple (本覚寺) and Masamune Tomb (正宗墓 )

48|Part 2 of — 14|Late Kamakura Period Sword : Early Soshu Den (鎌倉末刀)

This is a detailed section of Chapter 14| Late Kamakura Period Sword.  Please read Chapter 14 before this part.

0-timeline - size 24 Late Kamakura

                         The red circle above indicates the time we discuss in this section.

14 Ikubi kissaki Damadge

In Chapter 14, “Late Kamakura Period Sword (鎌倉末太刀),” the ikubi-kissaki sword is explained.  The illustration above shows a flaw caused when the damaged area was repaired.  To compensate for this flaw, swordsmiths developed a new sword style during the late Kamakura period.  They forged swords with a longer kissaki and lowered the tip of the hi below the yokote line.   This way, if the yokote line were lowered during repairs, the tip of the hi would remain below the yokote line.

15 Masamune (Sano)   15 Masamune hamon (Sano)

The above photo shows a sword by Goro Nyudo Masamune (五郎入道正宗).  Please observe the size and shape of the kissaki.  This differs from the previous ikubi-kissaki and ko-gissaki stylesThis style represents a typical late Kamakura period kissaki style.  It is o-suriage (a largely shortened form). 

Under the Kamakura Bakufu, many swordsmiths moved to KamakuraThey were Toroku Sakon Kunituna (藤六左近国綱) of the Yamashiro Awataguchi group (山城粟田口), Fukuoka Ichimonji Sukezane (福岡一文字助真), and Kunimune (国宗) from the Bizen area.  They were the origin of Soshu-den (相州伝)Eventually, Tosaburo Yukimitsu (藤三郎行光) and his famous son, Masamune (正宗), emergedIn the drawing above, kinsuji and inazuma are shown within the hamon.  The shining lines inside the hamon are inazuma and kinsuji.  Inazuma and kinsuji are collections of nie.  Masamune is well-known for his inazuma and kinsuji.  He lived in Kamakura, a seaside town, and his hamon resembles ocean waves when viewed from the side.

50 part 2 of 15 吉岡.photo 50 part 2 of 15 吉岡

The picture above shows a sword made by the swordsmith Yoshioka Ichimonji group (吉岡一文字).  The kissaki resembles one of Masamune’s swordsIt is longer than the previous ikubi-kissaki or ko-gissaki.  This is chu-gissaki.  The kissaki, like this, is one of the key points in determining the period when the sword was made.  The hamon has choji, gunome, togariba (pointed tip), and very tight nie.

50 part 2 of 15 運生 photo 50 part 2 of 15 運生 

The photo above shows a sword by Ukai Unsho (鵜飼雲生) from Bizen-den.  This sword is also from the late Kamakura period, but it has a ko-gissaki.  This sword does not have the late Kamakura period chu-gissaki style.  Narrow hoso-suguha are more characteristic of an earlier time than the late Kamakura periodThis sword indicates that swords do not always exhibit the style of their period.  To kantei*: first examine the style and shape, then give yourself an idea of the period it was made in.  However, the kissaki in this case does not indicate the late Kamakura period.  The next step is to look at the various characteristics of the sword one by one, such as the hamon, nie or nioi, ji-hada, etc., to determine the period, the den, and the province, and then come up with the name. This process is called kantei.

*Kantei – the process of identifying a swordsmith’s name by analyzing the sword’s characteristics without seeing the mei (the inscribed smith’s name).  The mei might be gone if it has been shortened.   All the photos above are from the Sano Museum Catalogue.  Permission to use them is granted.

47| Part 2 of –13 Late Kamakura Period: Genko (鎌倉末元寇)

This is a detailed section of Chapter 13, Late Kamakura Period, Genko(鎌倉末元寇).  Please read Chapter 13 before reading this section.

0-timeline - size 24 Late Kamakura

                      The red circle above indicates the time we discuss in this section.

Genko (元寇):  Mongolian Invasion 

Chapter 13 briefly describes the Mongolian invasion.  Here is a more detailed description.  The Mongol Empire was a vast empire that stretched from present-day Mongolia to Eastern Europe during the 13th and 14th centuries.  The grandson of Genghis Khan, Kublai Khan, sent several official letters to Japan demanding that it become a dependent state of the Mongol Empire (元: Yuan) and ordering Japan to send tribute.  They threatened Japan, warning that they would invade if Japan did not meet their demands.  Hojo Tokimune (北条時宗), who was in power at the Kamakura bakufu (government) at the time, refused and ignored the letters multiple times.  This led to two invasions by the Mongol Empire.  It is often said that a powerful typhoon hit Japan on each occasion, and these two powerful typhoons drove the Mongols away.  This is correct, but the whole story was much more than this.

Bun’ei-no-eki (文永の役)  1274

The first Mongolian invasion was called Bun’ei-no-eki.  In early October 1274, Mongol troops (Mongols, Han Chinese, and Koreans) totaling around 40,000 men* set out from the Korean Peninsula on about 900* large and small ships and headed toward Japan.  After arriving on Tsushima Island (対馬), Mongol soldiers burned villages and killed many residents, including local villagers.  Villagers were captured and sent to the top Mongol officials as slaves.  It was a heartbreaking scene. 

The Mongols moved to Iki Island (壱岐の島), Hizen Shore (肥前), Hirado Island (平戸)、Taka Island (鷹島), and Hakata Bay (博多).  In each location, the disastrous and sorrowful scenes were the same as everywhere.    On every battlefield, Japanese soldiers and villagers were killed in large numbers.  The Kamakura bakufu sent a large number of samurai troops into battle.  The Japanese forces sometimes won and pushed the Mongols back, but they mostly lost.  Many Japanese wives and children near the battlefields were captured. 

Eventually, no soldiers dared to fight the Mongols. The Mongols’ arrows were short and not very powerful, but they coated the tips with poison and shot them all at once like rain.  Also, this was the first time the Japanese faced firearms. The loud sound of explosions frightened horses and samurai.  Japanese troops had to retreat, and the situation was grim for them.  But one morning, there was a big surprise!  All the ships had vanished from the shore.  They were all gone on the morning of October 21 (today’s date, November 19).  All the Mongols had disappeared from the coast of Hakata

What happened was that the Mongols decided to end the fight and head back home.  The reason was that, although they were winning, they had also lost many soldiers and one of their key leaders in the army.  The Mongols realized that no matter how many victories they achieved, the Japanese kept coming more and more from everywhere.  Also, the Mongols realized they could not expect reinforcements from their homeland across the ocean.  Their supplies of weapons were running low.  The Mongols decided to go back.  However, there was a twist.  Around the end of October (November by today’s calendar), the sea between Hakata (where the Mongols were stationed) and Korea was very dangerous because of bad weather—only clear days with south winds allowed sailing across the sea.  The sea they had to cross is called Genkai Nada (玄界灘), known for its rough waters.  For some reason, the Mongols decided to go back during the night.  That was a mistake.  They might have caught a brief moment of the south wind, but it did not last long.  Consequently, they encountered a usual severe rainstorm.  Many ships collided with each other, crashed into cliffs, capsized, and people fell into the ocean.  Several wrecked vessels were found on the shores of Japan. 

The Mongol invasion ended here.  This war is called Bun’ei-no-eki (文永の役).  The Mongols lost many people, ships, soldiers, food, and weapons.  In fact, Korea suffered greatly.  They were forced to supply the Mongols with people, food, weapons, and more.  After the war, in Korea, only older men and children were left to work on farms.  Additionally, they faced both drought and prolonged rainfall.

Ko’an-no-eki (弘安の役) 1281

The second Mongolian invasion, known as Ko’an-no-eki, occurred in 1281.  After the first attempt to invade Japan, Kublai Khan kept sending messengers to Japan, demanding that Japan become a Mongol dependency.  The Kamakura bakufu ignored and executed these messengers.  Kublai Khan decided to attack Japan again in 1281.  His top advisers tried to persuade him not to go through with it because the ocean was too dangerous, the country was too small, the distance was too far, and there was nothing to gain even if they succeeded.  Despite these, Kublai Khan insisted on the attack. 

This time, they arrived in two groups.  One was the east-route troops with 40,000* soldiers on 900 ships, and the other was the south-route troops with 100,000* soldiers on 3,500 ships.  This was one of the largest forces in history.  They planned to depart from their designated port and meet on Iki Island (壱岐の島) by June 15 to fight together.  The east-route troops arrived there before the south-route troops.  Instead of  waiting for the south-route forces to arrive, the east-route troops started attacking Hakata Bay (博多) on their own.  However, since the previous invasion of the Bun’ei-no-eki, Japan had prepared for battle by building a 20-kilometer-long stone wall.  This stone wall was 3 meters high and 2 meters thick.  The troops had to give up landing at Hakata and moved to Shiga-no-Shima Island (志賀島).  There, the fight between the Mongols and Japanese was evenly matched, but ultimately, the east-route troops lost and retreated to Iki Island, where they decided to wait for the south-route forces to arrive. 

The south-route troops never arrived. They had changed their plans.  On top of that, while waiting for the south-route forces to come, they lost over 3,000 men to an epidemic.  Some suggested returning home because of the difficulties, but they chose to wait for the south-route troops as long as their supplies lasted. 

Meanwhile, the south-route troops decided to head to Hirado Island (平戸島), which was closer to Dazaifu (太宰府).  Dazaifu was the final and most important place they wanted to attack.   Later, the east-route troops found that the south-route troops had gone to Hirado Island.  Finally, the two forces joined on Hirado Island, with each group stationed on a nearby island called Takashima Island (鷹島).  The problem was that the ships were not easily maneuverable because this island had very high tides and low tides.

Meanwhile, 60,000 Japanese men headed toward the area where the Mongols were stationed.  Before the Japanese soldiers arrived to fight the Mongols, a massive typhoon struck on July 30, and the Mongols were caught in a huge storm.  Their ships collided, and many sank.  People fell overboard and drowned.

By this time, it had been about three months since the east-route troops left Mongolia in early May.  That means they had been at sea for roughly three months.  In northern Kyushu (九州), typhoons usually occur about 3.2 times between July and September.  The Mongols had been at sea and along Japan’s coast for around three months.  So, they were likely to be hit by a typhoon sooner or later.

The Mongol Empire lost 2/3 of its naval forces during the event at Ko’an-no-eki.   Even after the Mongols failed in two invasions, Kublai Khan still insisted on attacking Japan again, despite his advisers’ warnings not to.  Ultimately, the plan was delayed and then terminated due to numerous rebellions and upheavals, and no lumber was left to build ships.  Soon after, Kublai died in 1294.  Historical records of the Mongols indicate that Mongolian officials highly praised Japanese swords.  Some even suggest that one reason it was difficult to defeat Japan was because of its long, sharp swords. The experience of the Mongolian invasion changed the ikubi kissaki (猪首切先) sword into a new Soshu-den (相州伝) style.  The next chapter describes this new style of sword, the Soshu-den swords.

49 Photo of part 2 of 14 Late KamakuraThe stone wall scene.  Photo from Wikipedia.  Public Domain

* Number of soldiers by https://kotobank.jp/word/元寇-60419 .  Referred to several different reference sources.  They all have similar numbers of soldiers and ships.

45|Part 2 of –11 Ikubi Kissaki (continued from Chapter 44)

This chapter is a detailed section of Chapter 11, Ikubi-kissaki, and continues from Chapter 44|Part 2 of 11 Ikubi-kissaki Sword.  Please read Chapter 11 and Chapter 44 before proceeding with this section.

0-timeline - size 24 Middle Kamakura

 The red circle above indicates the time we discuss in this section.

Bizen Saburo Kunimune (備前三郎国宗)

Another swordsmith worth mentioning in this section is Bizen Saburo Kunimune (備前三郎国宗).  During the middle Kamakura period, the Hojo clan invited top swordsmiths to Kamakura.  Awataguchi Kunitsuna (粟田口国綱) from Yamashiro in Kyoto, Fukuoka Ichimonji Sukezane (福岡一文字助真) from the Bizen area, and Bizen Kunimune (備前国宗) from the Bizen area moved to Kamakura with their circle of people.  These three groups started the Soshu-den (相州伝).  Refer to Chapter 14, Late Kamakura Period Swords.

  • Sugata (shape)  ——————— Ikubi-kissaki style.  Sometimes Chu-gissaki.  Thick body.  Koshi-zori. Narrow Shinogi width.                                                                                                
  • Horimono (Engravings)  —————- Often narrow Bo-hi (single groove)
  • Hamon (Tempered line) ————- O-choji Midare (irregular large clove shape) with Ashi.  Or Ko-choji Midare (irregular small clove shape) with AshiNioi base with Ji-nie (Nie in the Hada area).  Some Hamon appear squarish with less Kubire (less narrow at the bottom of the clove).   Hajimi (刃染み rough surface) may show.  The Kunimune swords often show a lower part with Choji and an upper part with less activity without Ashi                                                                                                                                                                                                                        

Kunimune Compton 1 Kunimune Compton 2Bizen Saburo Kunimune (備前三郎国宗)   Photo from “Nippon-to Art Sword of Japan, ” The Walter A. Compton Collection.   National Treasure

  • Boshi  ———————— Small irregular.  Yakizume or short turn back.
  • Ji-hada —————-Wood-grain pattern.  Fine Ji-hada with some Ji-nie (Nie inside Ji-hada).  Midare-utsuri (irregular shadow) is visible.  A few Hajimi (rough surface).

12 (second part 2) 照国神社The above photo is from the official website of the Terukuni Jinja Shrine in Kyushu.    http://terukunijinja.pkit.com/page222400.html

This is the national treasure, Kunimune, preserved at the Terukuni Jinja Shrine in Kagoshima Prefecture.  See the photos on the previous page.  This Kunimune sword was lost after WWII.  Dr. Compton, chairman of the board at Miles Laboratories in Elkhart, Indiana, found it in an antique shop in Atlanta.  I mentioned Dr. Compton in Chapter 32, Japanese Swords, after World War II.  When he saw this sword, he realized it was not just an ordinary sword.  He bought it and inquired at the Nihon Bijutsu Token Hozon Kyokai (The Japanese Sword Museum) in Tokyo.  It turned out to be the famous missing national treasure, Kunimune, from the Terukuni Jinja shrineHe returned the sword to the shrine without compensation in 1963. 

My father became close friends with him around this time through Dr. Homma and Dr. Sato, both leading sword experts.  Later, Dr. Compton asked Dr. Honma and my father to examine his collection of swords at his house, where he had many, as well as those at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, the Philadelphia Museum of Art, and the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston.  My father wrote about this trip and the swords he examined in those museums and published a book in 1965 titled “Katana Angya (刀行脚).” 

For Dr. Compton and my father, those days must have been the best times of their lives.  Their business was doing well, and they could spend a lot of time on their interests and enjoy themselves.  It was also the best time for me.  One time, when I visited Compton’s house, he spent hours showing me his swords in the basement for hours, nearly all day.  His house was large, and the basement, which he had built as his study, had a fire prevention system. The lighting system was perfect for viewing swords and other art objects. 

His wife, Phoebe, told him he shouldn’t keep a young girl (I was a college student at the time) in the basement all day.  He agreed and took me to his cornfield to pick some corn for dinner.  From a basement to a cornfield, not much of an improvement?  So, Phoebe decided to take me shopping and have lunch in Chicago.  Good idea,  but it was too far.  Compton’s house was in Elkhart, Indiana.  The distance between Elkhart and Chicago was about 2.5 hours by car. It was too far just for shopping and lunch.  To my surprise, the company’s employee flew us to the rooftop of a department store, we did some shopping, had lunch, and then flew back.

Miles Laboratories and a well-known Japanese large pharmaceutical company had a business partnership at that time.  Dr. Compton frequently traveled to Japan for business purposes.  However, whenever he visited Japan, he spent days with sword people, including my father, and I usually followed him.  One of the female workers’ jobs at this pharmaceutical company was to translate the sword book into English. 

My parents’ house was filled with Miles’ products.  Miles Laboratories had a large research facility in Elkhart, Indiana.  I visited there several times.  One day, I sat with Dr. Compton in his office, looking into a sword book with our heads close together.  That day, movie actor John Forsythe visited the research lab.  He was the host of a TV program sponsored by  Miles Laboratories.  All the female employees were making a big fuss over him.  Then he entered Dr. Compton’s room to greet him, expecting the chairman to be sitting in his big chair at his desk, looking like a chairman.  But he saw Dr. Compton looking into the sword book seriously, with his head against mine.  Dr. Compton’s appearance was just like that of any chairman of the board of a major company, as one might imagine, and I was a Japanese college student looking like a college student.  John Forsythe showed a strange expression as if he did not know what to think.

 

 

 

40|Part 2 of — 7 Overview of Kamakura Period Sword (鎌倉太刀概要)

This chapter is a detailed part of Chapter 7, an overview of the Kamakura Period Swords.  Please read  Chapter 7, Overview of the Kamakura Period Swords, before reading this section. 

0-timeline - size 24 Kamakura Period

                         The red circle above indicates the time we discuss in this section.

The Kamakura period was a golden age of sword-making.  About half of the well-known swords today were produced during this time.  This is probably because the war between the Genji and the Heishi demanded many swords, and swordsmiths improved their skills through wartime experience.  Also, Emperor Gotoba (後鳥羽) invited many talented swordsmiths to his palace, treated them favorably, and encouraged them to create excellent swords by granting them high ranks.  During the Kamakura period, sword-making techniques greatly improved.

Middle Kamakura Period —- Yamashiro-den (山城伝)

The middle Kamakura period was the height of the Yamashiro-den.  Within the Yamashiro-den, there were three main groups: the Ayanokoji group (綾小路), Awataguchi group (粟田口), and Rai group (来).                                                                                                                       Among the Awataguchi group, six swordsmiths received the honor of “Goban-kaji ” from Emperor Gotoba (後鳥羽上皇).  Awataguchi is the name of an area in Kyoto. 

The Ayanokoji ( 綾小路 ) group lived in the Ayanokoji area of Kyoto.  My sword textbook had a note indicating that I had seen Ayanokoji Sadatoshi (綾小路定利) on March 22, 1972.  My note was brief, only a few words: o-suriage, funbari, narrowbody, and ji-nie

The Rai group originated from Rai Kuniyuki (来国行 ).  Rai Kuniyuki and Ayanokoji Sadatoshi were believed to have been close friends.  Rai Kuniyuki created many well-known swords.  His famous Fudo Kuniyuki (不動国行) was once owned by Shogun Ashikaga Yoshiteru (足利義輝 ), then passed to Matsunaga Danjo (松永弾正), then to Oda Nobunaga ( 織田信長 ), then to Akechi Mitsuhide (明智光秀 ), and eventually to Toyotomi Hideyoshi (豊臣秀吉).  All of them were historically famous and influential daimyo.  It is said that Toyotomi Hideyoshi held this sword during the memorial service for Oda Nobunaga.  Rai Kuniyuki’s son was Niji Kunitoshi.  He also forged well-known swords. 

Middle Kamakura Period —– Bizen-den (備前伝)                                                              

The Bizen-den during the Heian period was called Ko-bizen.  They are similar to those in the Yamashiro-den style.  The true height of the Bizen-den was during the middle Kamakura period.  The Bizen area (today’s Okayama Prefecture) had many ideal conditions for sword-making: a good climate, abundant iron resources, plenty of wood for fuel, and a convenient location.  Naturally, many swordsmiths moved there, and it became a major center for sword production. 

The Bizen region produced many swords of higher quality and superior to those of other sword groups and more famous swordsmiths.  Fukuoka Ichimonji Norimune (則宗) and his son Sukemune (助宗 ) received the honor of the Goban-kaji from Emperor Gotoba.   Among the Osafune group (長船), the famous Mitsutada (光忠) and Nagamitsu (長光) appeared.  My father owned four Mitsutada bladesThree tachis and one tanto.  He was so proud of owning four Mitsutada blades that he asked his tailor to monogram Mitsutada on the inside pocket of his suit jacket. 

From the Hatakeda group (畠田), Hatakeda Moriie (畠田守家), and from the Ugai (鵜飼) group, Unsho (雲生 ) and Unji (雲次) appeared.  The famous Kunimune (国宗) also emerged around this time.   Since many swordsmiths worked in the Bizen-den, many Bizen swords exist today.  Each swordsmith displayed his own characteristics in the swords.  Therefore, doing the kantei of Bizen swords can be quite complex. 

The classification of the sword ranking from the top

  1. Kokuho (国宝: National Treasure)
  2. Jyuyo Bunkazai (重要文化財: Important Cultural Property)
  3. Jyuyo Bijutsu Hin (重要美術品: Important Artwork)
  4. Juyo Token (重要刀剣: Important Sword)        more to follow

Here are my father’s four Bizen Osafune Mitsutada swords. He took these pictures many years ago at home. It is clear that he was not much of a photographer.  On a rectangular  sheet of white paper, he wrote the name of the swordsmith, the period when the sword was made, the name(s) of the daimyo who owned it in the past, and its classification.

img027               img028                Osafune Mitsutada (Juyo Bukazai)                 Osafune Mitsutada (Juyo Bunakzai)

img029            img030 Osafune Mitsutada (Juyo Token)                 Osafune Mitsutada(Juyo Bunkazai)

Late Kamakura Period —– Soshu Den (相州伝 )

Yamashiro-den began to decline in the latter part of the Kamakura period.  At this time, many swordsmiths moved to the Kamakura area under the new power of the Kamakura bakufu (鎌倉幕府), led by the Hojo clan.  The new group, Soshu-den (相州伝 ), began to emerge.  Fukuoka Ichimonji Sukezane (福岡一文字助真) and Kunimune (国宗) from Bizen moved to KamakuraToroku Sakon Kunitsuna (藤六左近国綱) from the Awataguchi group of Yamashiro-den also moved to Kamakura.  These three are considered the founders of the Soshu-den in Kamakura.  Kunitsunas son was Tosaburo Yukimitsu, and his grandson was the famous Masamune (正宗)Outside Kamakura, Yamashiro Rai Kunitsugu (来国次), Go-no-Yoshihiro (郷義弘) from the Ettchu (越中) province, and Samoji  (左文字) from Chikuzen Province (筑前) were active swordsmiths.

18| Nanboku-Cho Period Sword (南北朝太刀)

0-timeline - size 24 Nanboku-cho

                           The circle indicates the time we discuss in this section

During the Nanboku-cho period, samurai sought large, elaborate, impressive, yet practical swords.  The Soshu-den style sword from Nanboku-cho time was just that.    This was the most popular style at the time.  The Nanboku-cho period marked the peak and height of the Soshu-den sword.  Many swordsmiths moved from other provinces to the Kamakura area and forged Soshu-den style swords.  Other schools and provinces outside the Kamakura area also produced Soshu-den-style swords in their own areas.

 

19 Nanboku-cho Sword style

Sugata (姿: Shape) —————–The original length of a sword ranged from three to five feet, but it was later shortened to about two and a half feet.  A significantly shortened blade is called o-suriage. 

The Nanboku-cho style sword features shallow kyo-zori (also called torii-zori).  Refer to Chapter 5, Heian Period Sword.  The highest curvature occurs around the middle of the body. It has a wide body, high shinogi, narrow shinogi-ji  (Chapter 3, Names of parts),  and thin kasane (blade thickness), which are distinctive features of the Nanboku-cho style.  High gyo-no-mune or shin-no-mune, and sometimes a maru-mune (round back).

19 Nanboku-cho 3 kinds Mune

Hi (: groove) and Horimono (彫刻: engraving) ——– Often, a single hi (bo-hi), double hi, suken (dagger), Bonji (Sanskrit), and/or dragon are engraved on the shinogi-ji area.  Refer to Chapter 3, Names of Parts.

9 Hi, Suken, Bonji

Hamon (: Tempered line) —- The lower part of the body exhibits a narrow-tempered line; gradually, this line becomes wider and showier.  Course nie. O-midare (large, irregular, wavy hamon), Notare-midare (wavy, irregular hamon), and Gunome-midare (a combination of repeated half-circular and irregular hamon). Inazuma and kinsuji (see Chapter 14, Late Kamakura Period Sword) sometimes appear.

19 Hamon Notare 319 Mamon choji gunome19 Hitatsura Hamon Hiromitsu

                                  *From Sano Museum Catalogue ( Permission granted).

Ji-hada (地肌: the area between the shinogi and the tempered line) ———————-Wood-grain pattern (itame 板目). Sometimes tobiyaki (patchy tempered spots) appear on ji-hada.  For ji-hada, refer to Chapter 3, Names of Parts.

Kissaki (切っ先) and Boshi (tempered line at the kissaki area) ———- O-kissaki (long and large kissaki). Fukura kareru (less arc kissaki).  Midare-komi (the body and boshi have a similar tempered pattern), with kaeri-fukashi (hamon deeply turns back), and sometimes hitatsura (entirely tempered).  See the illustration above.

Sword-smiths during Nanboku-Cho Period Soshu Den (school)

  • From Soshu—————————————————Hiromitsu (広光)  Akihiro (秋広)  
  • From Yamashiro ———————————————Hasebe Kunishige (長谷部国重) 
  • From Bizen (called So-den Bizen)——-Chogi (長儀 )group  Kanemitsu (兼光 ) group 
  • From Chikuzen ———————————————————-Samoji (左文字 ) group

Chogi (長義)from The Sano Museum catalog. Permission to use is granted

The distinctive characteristics of the Nanboku-Cho period sword in the photo above      

  • The trace of an engraving of suken on the inside of the nakago indicates that this area was once a part of the main body.
  • Large and long kissaki

17| Nanboku-cho Period History 1333-1392(南北朝歴史)

0-timeline - size 24 Nanboku-cho

            The red circle above indicates the time we discuss in this section.

After Jokyu-no-ran (Chapter 10 Jokyu-no-ran), the power of the Imperial Court declined significantly.  The successor, the Hojo clan, which was a dominant force during the Kamakura period, also began to face financial difficulties and began to lose control over regional lords.  One reason was the costs incurred by the Mongol invasion.  The Kamakura bakufu (government) could not adequately reward the samurai who fought hard during the war.  As a result, they became very dissatisfied with the bakufu.  Seeing this as an opportunity, Emperor Go-Daigo attempted to attack the Kamakura bakufu twice but failed both times.  He was exiled to Oki Island.  In the meantime, Ashikaga Takauji (足利尊氏) and several groups of anti-Kamakura samurai gathered armed forces and succeeded in destroying the Kamakura bakufu in 1333.  This war ended the Kamakura period.                                                                                                                                                  

Emperor Go-Daigo, who had been exiled to Oki Island, returned to Kyoto and attempted political reforms.  This reform was known as Kenmu-no-chuko (or Kenmu-no-shinsei, 建武の中興).  However, his reforms failed to satisfy most of the ruling class.  Seeing an opportunity, Ashikaga Takauji attacked the Imperial Court in Kyoto, deposed Emperor Go-Daigo, and installed a member of a different branch of the Imperial family as emperor. 

Emperor Go-Daigo, however, insisted on his legitimacy, moved to Yoshino in the south of Kyoto, and established another Imperial court.  Thus, the Northern and  Southern Dynasties began.  With much strife between these rival courts and internal problems within each court,  more samurai groups began to move to the Northern Dynasty.  About sixty years later, the Southern Dynasty was forced to accept the Northern Dynasty’s proposal.  Consequently, the Northern Dynasty became the legitimate imperial court.  This sixty-year period is referred to as the Nanboku-cho or Yoshino-cho period. 

During the Nanboku-cho period, samurai preferred longer, more elaborate, yet practical swords.  The Soshu-den was at the height of its prominence.  However, the Soshu group was not the only one to produce Soshu-den-style swords.  Other schools and provinces in different areas also made Soshu-den-style swords.

Late Kamakura Period Swordsmiths (Early Soshu-Den time)

  • Tosaburo Yukimitsu (藤三郎行光)  
  • Goro Nyudo Masamune (五郎入道正宗)     
  • Hikoshiro Sadamune (彦四郎貞宗)

 17 Masamune hamon (Sano)             Masamune from Sano Museum Catalog (permission granted)

Nanboku-cho Period Swordsmiths  (Middle Soshu-Den time)

  • Hiromitsu (広光)   
  • Akihiro (秋広)

 20 Hitatsura Hiromitsu Hitatura )                  Hiromitsu from Sano Museum Catalog (permission granted)

Muromachi Period Swordsmiths (Late Soshu-Den time)

  • Hiromasa (広正)    
  • Masahiro (正広)